Skip to content
Español

Leave Us a Review

Our customers are the center of our universe and we’re grateful for them. If you’re willing to share your experience about your interaction with our agency, it’ll be a great help for other people looking to make smart and confident decisions about their insurance and financial services.


Take 60 seconds (or more if you want) to share your story by clicking on one of the review links below.

What our customers say about us...

Profile photo of Jordan Witt

Jordan Witt

December 19, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Jordan Witt
"Very helpful and always willing to answer Any questions regarding personal and business insurance"
We responded:
"Thank you so much for your thoughtful review! We’re proud to be part of this community and to provide insurance that’s both helpful and affordable. Whether it’s disability insurance, boat & watercraft coverage, or protecting local businesses with commercial and general liability policies, our team is always here to answer questions and lend a hand. We’re grateful for your trust and for the chance to serve our neighbors right here in Sun Prairie and beyond! -Andy"
Profile photo of Sandra Morel-Segura

Sandra Morel-Segura

December 19, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Sandra Morel-Segura
"Great customer service! Answered all my questions and was responsive in a timely manner."
We responded:
"Sandra, Thank you for the ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ review! We’re so glad you had a great experience with our team. Providing outstanding customer service, answering questions thoroughly, and responding quickly is what we strive for every client we serve. We’re proud to help individuals and families in Sun Prairie, WI, and the surrounding communities with their auto, home, renters, and life insurance needs. Thank you for trusting a local Sun Prairie insurance agency—we truly appreciate your support and look forward to being your go-to insurance resource for years to come! -Andy "
Profile photo of Jean Koehn

Jean Koehn

December 17, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Jean Koehn
"I had a fantastic experience working with Matt Steinmetz! He was incredibly knowledgeable and patient, taking the time to walk me through all my coverage options and ensuring I understood everything. Saved us a significant amount of money and providing better coverage for us. I highly recommend Matt to anyone looking for an agent who genuinely cares about their client's best interests and provides outstanding service!"
We responded:
"Thank you so much for this incredible 5-star review, Jean! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ We’re thrilled to hear about your fantastic experience with Matt Steinmetz. Matt truly takes pride in being knowledgeable, patient, and thorough—making sure every coverage option is clearly explained so our customers feel confident in their decisions. Saving you a significant amount of money while improving your coverage is exactly the kind of value we strive to deliver. Your recommendation means a lot to our entire team. Providing outstanding service and genuinely putting our clients’ best interests first is what we’re all about. If anyone is looking for trusted auto insurance, property insurance, or boat & watercraft insurance, Matt and our team are always happy to help compare options and find the best fit. Thank you again for choosing us—we appreciate your trust and look forward to being your insurance team for years to come! 🚗🏡🚤"
Profile photo of Deborah Tannah

Deborah Tannah

December 10, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Deborah Tannah
"Very pleasant to talk to. Provided information on their policies and compared to what I currently have in a clear and understandable way without being aggressive. Would recommend talking with the knowledgeable agents at this office"
We responded:
"Deborah, Thank you so much for the thoughtful review and strong recommendation! Our team truly appreciates your kind words. We take pride in being friendly, knowledgeable insurance agents who provide clear communication and a no-pressure experience. One of the things we love most is comparing insurance policies side by side—explaining the differences in coverage, limits, deductibles, and pricing—so everything is easy to understand. We believe education is essential when choosing the right insurance. By reviewing and comparing auto insurance, home insurance, renters insurance, and life insurance options, we help our customers make informed, confident decisions that fit their needs and budget. As a trusted local insurance agency, our goal is to be transparent, helpful, and focused on what’s best for you—not aggressive sales tactics. Thank you again for recommending our local insurance office. We’re proud to serve Sun Prairie and neighboring communities and be a go-to resource for reliable insurance quotes, coverage reviews, and personalized insurance solutions. We look forward to continuing to help with all your insurance needs now and in the future! -Andy"
Profile photo of Kory Meyers

Kory Meyers

December 8, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Kory Meyers
"They got back to me quickly and provided speedy service to get my car covered."
We responded:
"Kory, We love hearing this—thank you! Getting customers taken care of quickly is what our State Farm team strives for every day. We're glad we could provide fast service and get your auto insurance set up right away. Thanks for choosing our Sun Prairie office! -Andy"
Profile photo of Pamela Wilcox

Pamela Wilcox

November 20, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Pamela Wilcox
"Called the State Farm office and they picked up right away and sent me what I was looking for. Very easy."
We responded:
"Thank you for the fantastic review! 🎉 We love hearing that our State Farm team picked up right away and had exactly what you needed ready to go. Fast, friendly, and super easy—that’s what we aim for every single day! If you ever need auto, home, renters, or life insurance in Sun Prairie or anywhere in Wisconsin, our team is here and excited to help. We truly appreciate you choosing our office! -Andy"
Profile photo of Douglas Thomas Ryddner

Douglas Thomas Ryddner

November 7, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Douglas Thomas Ryddner
"Matt did some great work getting us set up with Auto and Home Insurance."
We responded:
" Thank you so much for the 5-star review! We’re thrilled to hear that Matt was able to get you set up with Auto and Home Insurance so smoothly. He works hard to make the process easy and clear, and our whole team appreciates the opportunity to help protect what matters most to you. If you ever have questions, need to make adjustments, or want to explore additional coverage options, our State Farm office here in Sun Prairie is always just a call, text, or visit away. Thanks again for trusting us with your insurance needs! -Andy"
Profile photo of Lisa Koenig

Lisa Koenig

November 6, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Lisa Koenig
"Matt was fantastic. So helpful and made the process of switching insurance so easy!"
We responded:
"Thank you so much for the 5-star review! We’re excited to hear you found a great price, and we love hearing how fantastic Matt was in helping make the switch to new coverage so quick and easy. Our team takes pride in simplifying the process and making sure you feel confident every step of the way! We’re grateful for the opportunity to help with your life insurance and auto insurance needs here in the Sun Prairie community. If you ever need support, have questions, or want to review coverage options, our whole team is here and ready to help! Thanks again for choosing the Andy Eyers State Farm team! -Andy"
Profile photo of Allison Barton

Allison Barton

November 5, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Allison Barton
"Andy is very thorough and helpful! Quick to respond with sound advice."
We responded:
"Thank you so much for the awesome 5-star review, Allison! 🎉 Our team at the Andy Eyers State Farm Insurance Agency in Sun Prairie works hard to be thorough, quick to respond, and packed with helpful, sound insurance advice. We’re thrilled to hear you had a great experience! If you ever need support with home, auto, life, or business insurance, our local Sun Prairie team is always here and ready to help. Thanks for choosing us — we’re proud to be your trusted insurance resource! -Andy"
Profile photo of James Nettenstrom

James Nettenstrom

November 3, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by James Nettenstrom
"Very responsive to all my requests."
We responded:
"James, We appreciate you taking the time to share your experience! Our team is excited to know that our responsiveness and fair pricing made a positive difference for your auto and property insurance needs. Helping families protect what matters most here in the Sun Prairie area is truly a team effort, and we’re grateful to be your local insurance office. Thank you for choosing our team for your coverage — we’re here anytime you need support or guidance! -Andy"
Profile photo of Diana Long

Diana Long

October 30, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Diana Long
"I am very happy to be back with StateFarm. Always a quick, understandable response."
We responded:
"Thank you Diana for taking time to review our office! I'm pleased to hear that you enjoyed meeting with Matt and seeing the difference that State Farm has offer! We love having you back and we appreciate you! -Andy "
Profile photo of Madonna Bigelow

Madonna Bigelow

October 21, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Madonna Bigelow
"The Andy Eyers State Farm staff was so swift to handle my needs when we had a family emergency. They were supportive, thorough, professional and great in the help for me. I highly recommend them."
We responded:
"Madonna, Thank you so much for your kind words and recommendation. We’re truly glad our team could be there for you during such an important time. Our goal is always to provide quick, caring, and reliable support when it’s needed most. We appreciate your trust in Andy Eyers State Farm and are always here to help your family stay protected. -Andy"
Profile photo of Taylor Schultz

Taylor Schultz

October 21, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Taylor Schultz
"Great agent and team! Easy to work with and communicate, always great service."
We responded:
"Taylor, Thank you so much for your kind words! We truly appreciate your trust in our team. Communication and great service are what we strive for every day, and it means a lot to know you’ve experienced that with us. We’re always here to help whenever you need us! -Andy "
Profile photo of Sara Mork

Sara Mork

October 21, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Sara Mork
"My favorite part about working with Andy, is that he always responds right away!"
We responded:
"Sara, Thank you so much for sharing your experience! We’re thrilled to hear that Andy’s quick responses and personal attention have made a difference for you. Our team at Andy Eyers State Farm in Sun Prairie takes pride in being reliable, responsive, and truly there when our customers need us most. Whether it’s questions about auto, home, or life insurance, we’re always just a call or message away. We appreciate your trust and are grateful to have you as part of our State Farm family! -Andy"
Profile photo of Katie Myers

Katie Myers

October 21, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Katie Myers
"Andy and his team are easy to work with and experts in life insurance. You are working with a great team at this office!"
We responded:
"Thank you so much for your kind words, Katie! We truly appreciate your trust and support. Our team takes great pride in making life insurance simple and personalized for every family we work with. It means a lot to know that came through — thanks for being part of our State Farm family! -Andy"
Profile photo of Kari Kurtz

Kari Kurtz

October 3, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Kari Kurtz
"Matt Steinmetz Helped me get the best policy to fit my needs, he very kind and super informative. I highly recommend him."
We responded:
"Kari, Thank you for your kind words! We’re so glad to hear that Matt was able to take the time to walk you through your options and find the policy that best fits your needs. His kindness and knowledge make him such a valuable part of our team, and we truly appreciate your recommendation! Welcome to the State Farm Family! -Andy"
Profile photo of julie sundaram

julie sundaram

October 2, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by julie sundaram
"Andy is great! Always responds quickly. He and all his office are very personable, detail oriented and knowledgable. Also Andy Eyers supports local high school sports and music programs. THANK YOU!"
We responded:
"Thank you so much for the wonderful review, Julie! We’re grateful for your kind words about our team and the support we strive to provide. It means a lot to know you appreciate our responsiveness and attention to detail. Supporting our local high school sports and music programs is something we truly value—it’s just one way we can give back to this great community. We appreciate your trust and the opportunity to be your good neighbor! -Andy"
Profile photo of John King

John King

October 1, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by John King
"Great customer service!"
We responded:
"Thanks for the shout out on our great customer service, John! We appreciate you taking your time to review your experience with us! -Andy"
Profile photo of Paula Mueller

Paula Mueller

September 30, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Paula Mueller
"I love Andy and State Farm! Always incredibly responsive and helpful!"
We responded:
"Paula, Thank you so much for your kind words! I truly appreciate your trust in me for your home and auto insurance, and I can’t tell you how much I enjoy working with you. It means the world to know you feel supported and taken care of. I’m also so grateful to have you as part of our Sun Prairie community. Please know I’m always just a call or email away whenever you need anything! -Andy"
Profile photo of Jim Schultz

Jim Schultz

September 25, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Jim Schultz
"Andy has been very responsive to my emails."
We responded:
"Jim, Thank you for your kind words! We’re glad to hear Andy was able to respond quickly and keep things moving smoothly for you. Our goal is always to be prompt, helpful, and available whenever our customers need us. We truly appreciate your feedback and the opportunity to serve you! -Andy"
Profile photo of Herb Britsch

Herb Britsch

September 22, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Herb Britsch
"Matt Steinmetz has been fantastic to work with—always professional, responsive, and helpful. He takes the time to clearly explain coverage options and ensure I get the best fit for my home and auto insurance. Highly recommend!"
We responded:
"Thank you so much for the wonderful review, Herb! We’re so glad to hear that Matt has been fantastic to work with and that he’s been able to walk you through your coverage options with care and clarity. Providing that kind of personal, responsive service is always our goal, and we’re grateful for your trust in us for your home and auto insurance. We truly appreciate your recommendation and look forward to being here whenever you need us!Herbert! -Andy"
Profile photo of 4usGodis

4usGodis

September 19, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by 4usGodis
"quick transfer insurance and new id cards sent out by email"
We responded:
"Thank you for sharing your experience! We’re glad we could make the insurance transfer process quick and easy for you and get your new ID cards sent out right away. Our team always aims to provide efficient and reliable service, and we appreciate you trusting us with your insurance needs! -Andy"
Profile photo of Jesse Myers

Jesse Myers

September 17, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Jesse Myers
"As a contractor, at times we work with various insurance companies. Andy at State Farm is always attentive and trustworthy, helping to make situation whole again."
We responded:
"Thank you for sharing such a thoughtful review! As a contractor, you see firsthand how important it is to have an insurance partner who is responsive and dependable when things don’t go as planned. Our team here at Andy Eyers State Farm in Sun Prairie takes pride in being attentive and trustworthy, whether we’re helping customers directly or supporting great contractors like you in making situations whole again. We truly value the partnership and look forward to continuing to work together whenever the need arises. -Andy "
Profile photo of Michael Hommerding

Michael Hommerding

September 3, 2025

1  out of  5
rating by Michael Hommerding
"Had my car repossessed. Honda listed out everything I needed from the insurance company. Binder page, shows who the driver is, full insurance on it, and the lein holder being a PO Box for a Sacramento address. Figured this would be a one call thing. It turned into 4 calls spanning about a week. They failed to list me on the page the first time, the next time didn’t have me listed at all according to Honda, the next one was missing a digit in the PO Box number and had Sacramento spelled Sacremento. I know this because I was CC’d on the third email. Even though I told them exactly what I needed on the form, they disregarded what I said and sent it however they liked. Then when I called back and told them I am up in arms over this. I was told that it automates the address and PO Box. If that’s the case how does it automate to spell Sacramento wrong? After I said I was up in arms over all this. Andy then threatened to call the police on me for threatening them? Saying “I’d come in guns blazing”.. which was never said. They’re phone calls are recorded… he then sent our policy to a different agents office. They noticed the errors, corrected them, and sent the email correctly the first try. Something Andy and his team couldn’t do."
We responded:
"Out of concern for my team’s safety, I made the difficult decision to transfer your parents’ account to another agent they already had an existing relationship with. We have a strict zero-tolerance policy when it comes to threats, as protecting our team must always come first. I understand this may feel disappointing, but I do want to be clear that the other statements you shared don’t reflect what actually occurred. We’ll continue to let our many reviews speak to the kind of service and support our customers experience with us. I truly wish you and your family the best moving forward with your new agent. -Andy"
Profile photo of Mary Muzzio Opalewski

Mary Muzzio Opalewski

August 27, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Mary Muzzio Opalewski
"I just wanted to take a moment to express my gratitude for your outstanding support, Andy Eyers. This is the best insurance agency ever! Whenever I have called in emergencies, you have always been there with a kind voice to help and to guide on next steps. Thank you for everything you do!"
We responded:
"Mary, Thank you so much for taking the time to share such a thoughtful review! We are truly honored to be called the best insurance agency, and it means the world to know you feel supported by our team. Emergencies and unexpected situations can be stressful, and we want every customer to feel reassured that when they call, they’ll be greeted with kindness, patience, and clear guidance on next steps. Our entire team at Andy Eyers State Farm is dedicated to being a reliable resource for your auto, home, life, and business insurance needs—whether it’s a quick question or a challenging situation. We are so grateful for your trust and look forward to continuing to be here whenever you need us. -Andy"