
State Farm® Insurance Agent Andy Eyers
Leave Us a Review
Our customers are the center of our universe and we’re grateful for them. If you’re willing to share your experience about your interaction with our agency, it’ll be a great help for other people looking to make smart and confident decisions about their insurance and financial services.
Take 60 seconds (or more if you want) to share your story by clicking on one of the review links below.
What our customers say about us...
Chris Barrett
July 28, 2025
"Incredibly friendly, helpful, and honest office that leaps to help the instant you contact them."
"Thank you so much for the kind words! We truly appreciate you taking the time to share your experience. Our team takes pride in being responsive, honest, and helpful—we’re always here when you need us! We appreciate you! -Andy"
Sandy Randall
July 21, 2025
"I am super happy with everyone I talked with regarding rolling my leased vehicle into a new one. Everyone was super quick to respond in a friendly, supportive and professional way. Thanks for being so amazing. Smiles, Sandy"
"Thank you Sandy for the great review of Matt! We are glad to help you get better coverage and save alot of money, while answering questions and giving you peace of mind with your coverage! We appreciate you! -Andy "
Dalia Guzman
July 17, 2025
"Great office and attentive staff!"
"Thank you so much for the kind words! We're glad to hear you had a great experience with our office and staff. We’re always here to help whenever you need us! -Andy "
Wendy Ward
July 16, 2025
"Great communication and flexibility. Very friendly and helpful."
"Thank you for your thoughtful feedback! We're so glad you appreciated our communication and flexibility. It's always our goal to be friendly, helpful, and available when you need us. We truly appreciate your support! -Andy"
Seth Newman
July 16, 2025
"Great people and even better service!"
"Thanks Seth! We appreciate the shout out. We appreciate you! -Andy"
Emily Ockenga
July 16, 2025
"I was with another auto/homeowners insurance company for 10+ years and was highly disappointed with the service I'd received after having been a long-time client. I switched to Andy's group with State Farm a few years ago and have been incredibly happy with the decision. Not only is the team EASY to get ahold of AND responsive, they're also great at explaining various polices in ways the average person can understand. I've also known Andy and his wife for well over 15 years and can attest that what you see is what you get. The people Andy has working on his team are no exception to that. You're really doing yourself a favor by going with these guys."
"Thank you so much for your incredible review and kind words! We’re truly honored that you made the switch after so many years elsewhere, and we’re thrilled to hear that you’ve been happy with the decision. Clear communication, accessibility, and treating people with honesty and care are at the heart of everything we do — and it means the world to hear that reflected in your experience. We also truly appreciate the personal connection and trust you’ve had in us over the years. It’s people like you who make our work so meaningful. Thank you for your continued support! -Andy"
Jesse Myers
July 10, 2025
"It's been great having Andy & Matt as our insurance agents, there never farther than a phone call away. Jesse"
"Thank you, Jesse! We truly appreciate your kind words. It’s been a pleasure working with you, and we’re always just a phone call away whenever you need us. Thanks for trusting Matt and me with your insurance needs! We appreciate you! — Andy"
Mary Francis
July 8, 2025
"I am handicapped and appreciative of a Home visit. Mary Francis"
"Thank you, Mary! We love serving our customers and home visits are just another way that we do that. We appreciate you and supporting local business! -Andy Eyers Agent "
Sanket Shah
July 7, 2025
"The agency in my agent are awesome! They are really prompt in responding back to my inquiries and my questions. I would definitely recommend this particular State Farm agency if you are thinking about switching your insurance carrier, especially if you are in the Madison area."
"Thank you for taking time to review your experience with the office and our great customer service! That is very important to us and we thank you for trusting us with the things that matter most to you. We appreciate you! -Andy"
Miriam Mraz
July 3, 2025
"Matt has been super easy to work with. He responds quickly to questions and explains things in a manner that is easy to understand."
"Thank you, Miriam for your kind words about Matt and our customer service! Making insurance easy and educational is a top priority for us! We appreciate you! -Andy "
Chudley
July 2, 2025
"Thank you! Had a minor issue trying to get certain items listed on my policy. Omar and later Alec were extremely friendly and helpful."
"Thank you Chudley for rating Omar and Alec 5 stars! Service is our passion and are glad to hear you loved our friendly service! We appreciate you! -Andy"
Dana Joyce
July 2, 2025
"My experiences with Andy Eyers and Matt Steinmetz have always been exceptional. Their experience and knowledge shines through and it is always a joy to work with them. If you are looking for an agency that truly cares about their customers, this is it!"
"Thank you for reviewing our State Farm Agency! We're thrilled to know you had a positive experience; your satisfaction is our top priority! We look forward to continuing to work with you. We appreciate you! -Andy"
Steven Spice
June 23, 2025
"Service was excellent"
"Fantastic! Thank you Steven for giving our service 5 stars! We appreciate you! -Andy"
Shannon Schmelzer
May 31, 2025
"Omar was great help assisting me with my claim on accident. Very caring and understanding. What an amazing employee you have!"
"Thank you Shannon for the kind words for us! Who doesn't love a great deal! We appreciate you trusting us! Thank you! -Andy"
Christine Olszewski
May 15, 2025
"We recently went to State Farm to review our insurance policies with our new agent, Matt. He took the time to review all our policies and answer all our questions. When calling State Farm, Omar has helped us to clarify any questions we have had. The customer service provided by these two gentlemen has been phenomenal and greatly appreciated! Thank you!"
"Christine- Thank you for taking time to give Matt and Omar shout outs for thier wonderful customer service! We appreciate you! -Andy"
Santiago Currea
May 7, 2025
"Alec provides excellent boaters insurance and is an upstanding young gentlemen! Keep it up"
"Santiago, Thank you so much for the kind words! We're thrilled to hear that Alec provided excellent service and made a great impression. We truly appreciate your support and look forward to serving you again! -Andy "
Aaron Williams
May 7, 2025
"alec gave amazing boat insurance for my longliner. highly recommend"
"Thank you for reviewing your experience with Alec! He is a great asset to our team! -Andy "
Grace Conroy
May 7, 2025
"great auto insurance rates and super nice!!"
"We love hearing that you enjoyed your experience with our office, Grace! Who doesn't like saving money on insurance and getting great coverage? 😀 -Andy"
Mason Fairchild
May 7, 2025
"Great customer service, timely and responsive. Have recommended them to friends and family"
"Thank you for your wonderful review, Mason! We're so glad to hear you had a positive experience with our customer service and that Alec was timely and responsive. Your recommendation to friends and family means the world to us! -Andy"
Leo Forney
May 7, 2025
"Amazing service. Got a great home, life, and auto insurance bundle for my wife and I. Extremely good rates. Alec will hook you up with the best!"
"Wow—thank you for the awesome review! We're thrilled Alec could hook you and your wife up with a top-notch bundle for home, life, and auto insurance. Getting great coverage at great rates is what we’re all about. We appreciate the shoutout and are always here when you need us! -Andy"
Kevin Czerwinski
May 7, 2025
"Fantastic service, 10/10"
"Thanks Kevin for taking the time to review our agency and customer service! We pride ourselves on great customer service from a local agency. We appreciate you! -Andy "
Lon Slonaker
May 7, 2025
"They are always prompt and answer all my questions. I would highly recommend them for all types of insurance."
"Thank you, Lon! We appreciate your kind words and taking time to review your experience with our office. We appreciate you! -Andy "
Ritchie Mattingly
May 2, 2025
"Bought a new car in December of 2024 when Brian Cowan was still my agent told him to remove 1 car the same day now it is May and I've tried 4 times since talking to Andy, Omar and Matt and the car is still on my policy. I even sent proof of insurance from the new owner on the car that was removed. Even today May 2nd Matt asked what I wanted do with that car. I had everything transferred to a new agent."
"Hi Ritchie, I'm sorry to hear that you're not satisfied with our service. After reviewing your account notes, I saw that you first brought this issue to our attention last week, regarding an error that originated back in December with your prior Agent. As soon as we were made aware, we took immediate action to address the situation. We submitted and escalated a cancellation request on your behalf to resolve the matter as quickly and efficiently as possible. Once we received a response, we reached out to share the update with you. At that point, you expressed a desire to switch agents. Our intent in following up was simply to confirm how you’d like us to proceed based on the latest information. We take customer service seriously and have done everything within our power to assist you and reach a positive resolution. We sincerely wish you the best with your new agent. If there's anything we can do for you in the future, please don't hesitate to reach out. Thank you, Andy "
Jordan Puccio
April 25, 2025
"I was able to cut my car insurance bill (for THREE cars) by half of what I had been paying with Progressive, even after being with them for four years, by switching over. Matt was extremely helpful and thorough in explaining what would work best for my family long term. I’ll be recommending my friends who have other insurances to check out what kind of savings they can get as well. I was shocked to find out that with an additional policy and even MORE coverage than before, I am still paying significantly less with Andy’s team at State Farm. Thanks again to Matt for making sure I understood exactly what I was getting and helping me set my family up for success!"
"Thank you for taking time to review your fantastic experience with our office, Jordan! We know savings are sure great, and getting better coverage is even better! We appreciate you and trusting us to protect the things that matter most to you! -Andy"
Steve Murphy
January 10, 2025
"Paid State Farm premiums for many years for home and auto, but when we needed to make a claim they failed us. We should have stayed with American Family who had always treated us fairly."
"Steve, this is concerning to hear this was your experience. It is certainly different than what we hear from our customers. I will reach out to you in the morning to learn more. This is the first time we are hearing of any frustrations from you. We look forward to talking with you tomorrow to get to the bottom of this. ** We have tried reaching out multiple times to help, but have yet to hear back from you. Please reach out to us at your earliest convenience so we can assist!** -Andy"